Wednesday, July 12, 2023

Why so many stories in the Talmud?

TALMUD WATCH: Why Does the Talmud Include So Many Stories? The stories in the Talmud demonstrate the important difference between the law and the application of the law (Paul Socken, Jewish Journal).

The subtitle answers the question in the headline. But the article illustrates the point with — of course! — a story.

Why would volumes of intricate discussions of law include stories that are anything but legal? Stories that tell of demons, recount interpersonal relations, and often delve into the realm of the mystical are seemingly out of place in such a context. A fascinating example is found in Kiddushin 29b. The rabbis are discussing who should be sent to study at the yeshiva, the father or the son. The rabbis decide, surprisingly to the modern mind, that it should be the father unless the son is unusually gifted.

Visit PaleoJudaica daily for the latest news on ancient Judaism and the biblical world.