| PaleoJudaica.com A weblog on ancient Judaism and its context E-mail: paleojudaica-at-talktalk-dot-net ("-at-" = "@", "-dot-" = ".") |
|
Monday, November 07, 2005 A DISTANCE-LEARNING COURSE ON THE DEAD SEA SCROLLS at the University of Copenhagen: The Faculty of Theology of the University of Copenhagen is pleased to announce an MA-level Distance Learning Course: "Introduction to the Dead Sea Scrolls". (From Søren Holst on the g-Megillot list.) posted by Jim Davila | 11:26 AM CONGRATULATIONS TO THE JOURNAL OF SEMITIC STUDIES, which will celebrate its 50th anniversary on 16 November. posted by Jim Davila | 9:24 AM THE THIRD-CENTURY "CHURCH" AT MEGIDDO is the subject of a somewhat more temperate article ("Site May Be 3rd-Century Place of Christian Worship") in the Washington Post. Excerpts: Judging by the age of broken pottery discovered on the floor, the distinctive mosaic style, inscriptions citing Jesus and the apparent pre-Byzantine design of the building, state archaeologists said the structure was most likely a public place of Christian worship that dates to the mid-3rd or early 4th century. If true, the find would join the early 3rd-century Christian gathering place at Dura Europus in Syria as one of the oldest of its kind.posted by Jim Davila | 9:14 AM THE LUBAVITCHER REBBE is the subject of a conference at New York University: "Reaching for the Infinite:" Scholars At NYU On the Lubavitcher Rebbe The article doesn't mention that some Lubavitchers believe he was the messiah. UPDATE: Steven Weiss is attending the conference and has put up a number of posts on it already. posted by Jim Davila | 9:13 AM Sunday, November 06, 2005 A DICTIONARY OF MANICHAEAN TEXTS is in the works: Dictionary of Manichaean Texts being compiled in Britain Most cool. posted by Jim Davila | 10:27 AM ANCIENT CHRISTIAN CHURCH found at Megiddo: Prison dig reveals church that may be the oldest in the world There's also a photo of one of the inscriptions. posted by Jim Davila | 10:23 AM Saturday, November 05, 2005 THE EGYPTIAN BLOGGER who was arrested on 26 October has generated scarcely any interest in the mainstream media so far. But here are a few posts from another Egyptian blogger with more info and links. At the moment Technorati is listing 53 blog posts about him, but there are probably more, since it often takes a day or so for Technorati to cycle through. Glenn Reynolds also points to a petition from the Committee to Protect Bloggers which asks for Abdolkarim Nabil Seliman's release. I've signed it. I hope you will too. In addition, on Friday I sent the following note to the Egyptian Embassy in London (info@egyptianconsulate.co.uk): Dear Sir, Please feel free to write a note of protest to the Egyptian Embassy in your country. In the USA the e-mail address of the Egyptian Embassy is embassy@egyptembdc.org. If you live in a country other than Britain or the USA, you can find the relevant e-mail address easily through Google. Please do be polite (abusive letters are counterproductive) but also firm. The main points are that Mr. Seliman's right to free speech (whatever one thinks of his views), including the right to criticize his government and religious views with which he disagrees, should be respected and he should be released without charge immediately. My understanding is that there is not a right to free speech in Egypt, so this should be presented as a universal human right. You may want to point out also the very negative international publicity that is arising from reports of this incident. Feel free to poach any of the language in my e-mail if it applies to you. I encourage you to do this. Such messages do make a difference and could be very important in this case. Thanks. Okay, now back to ancient Judaism and related matters. UPDATE: There's good news and bad news (see here too). Only the good news is pretty bad too. Do send that e-mail. posted by Jim Davila | 10:20 AM A NEW BLOG ON HEBREW MANUSCRIPTS: Giluy Milta B'alma, a new blog by Dr. Ezra Chwat, has the purpose of providing informal preliminary publications of interesting Hebrew manuscript finds, especially from the Cairo Geniza. Here's the blurb: Working from the Institute of Microfilmed Hebrew Manuscripts in the National Library in Jerusalem, we present here new and interesting findings in Hebrew Manuscripts, particularly the Cairo Genizah. This is a good place to announce preliminary findings, and get feedback from fellow scholars. We welcome posts in Hebrew or English. They will be archived in hardcopy for bibliographic reference. (Via Hagahot.) posted by Jim Davila | 8:56 AM THE 40TH ANNIVERSARY OF NOSTRA AETATE was observed in a conference in Jerusalem last week: Catholics Want Message of Respect for Jews to Continueposted by Jim Davila | 8:42 AM Friday, November 04, 2005 ANOTHER INFORMAL SEGERT OBITUARY, this one by his student Tom Finley, posted by Ed Cook on Ralph. posted by Jim Davila | 3:46 PM THE LIBRARY OF ALEXANDRIA is the subject of an article ("Library, most magnificient") in the Hindu, for reasons unclear to me. It collects a lot of traditional material quite uncritically. For some evaluation of some of that material, see this post and its final link. posted by Jim Davila | 10:03 AM COPTOLOGY CONFERENCE COMING IN EGYPT: Scene set for Coptic studies UPDATE: It sounds like an interesting conference, but if this story is accurate, maybe I shouldn't attend: Egypt arrests blogger Criticising the Salafis and the Egyptian Government. What could he have been thinking? According to this article, the poor guy's mother even had to condemn him to stay out of trouble. For more on those riots, see this AP article . For more on the detention of Abdolkarim Nabil Seliman see here (includes links to his blogs if you read Arabic) and here. posted by Jim Davila | 9:35 AM THE TREE OF LIFE synagogue mosaics exhibition at the Brooklyn Museum is reviewed by the Forward in "The Roman Era, Revised". (Requires free registration). Excerpt: "If you were wealthy, you could afford marble and the poor had plaster floors," [archaeologist and cultural property lawyer Lucille] Roussin said, meaning it [the synagogue floor at Hamman-Lif] was likely that this community was someplace in between. The inscriptions on the floor were written in Latin, the least common language for Jews of the period, trailing Greek and Aramaic. This suggests a high level of comfort with the prevailing culture. The designs also speak loudly. Some scholars believe that elaborate figurative images may indicate that the communities' interpretation of Jewish law was less strict — much like Reform Judaism today — than in places where only the geometric mosaics condoned by the rabbis are found. It is also possible that the Jews of Hammam-Lif simply had less knowledge of Jewish law coming together in Israel and in Babylonia.posted by Jim Davila | 9:27 AM Thursday, November 03, 2005 FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF JUNK PHILOLOGY: The Axis of Logic has a long rant against Israel et al. by Ghali Hassan. My interest here is mainly in the first few paragraphs. The bold-font emphasis below is mine. Critical Analysis This is quite wrong. All these languages, including Hebrew and Arabic, do have an ancestral language that is called "Proto-Semitic" for the sake of convenience. ("Semitic" comes from the legendary biblical ancestor "Shem" in the book of Genesis.) Proto-Semitic broke up into various Semitic languages and proto-languages before writing was available, so no texts survive in it, but its existence is clear from linguistic reverse-engineering of the surviving Semitic languages. This is elementary knowledge to anyone trained in Semitic philology. With the rise of European racism against minorities in the 19th century, European Jews where [sic] targeted. Differences between Jews and other European citizens have to be manufactured. Since European Christians (the Protestant Reformists) adopted the Hebrew bible, religion was not an option for those differences. The Jews were identified as ‘Semites’ based on the incorrect assumption that their ancestors spoke Hebrew, which wasn’t the case. Ancient Hebrew tribes were Aramaic speakers. This is bizarre. It is perfectly clear from the Hebrew Bible and numerous Iron Age Hebrew inscriptions that Hebrew was the language spoken by the ancient Judeans and Israelites. If I may quote myself: While I am discussing inscriptions, it is worth noting that the epigraphic evidence makes it clear that speakers of Hebrew engaged in a monumental building project in Jerusalem around 700 (the Siloam Tunnel inscription). Other excavated Hebrew inscriptions in Jerusalem around this time include the Silwan tomb inscription, the Ophel ostracon, and an ostracon from Arad that mentions "the king of Judah." Substantial corpora of Judean Hebrew correspondence by worshipers of YHWH were found on ostraca from the end of the Iron Age (late 600s to 586/87) at Lachish and Arad. The Lachish letters mention "the king" (##3, 5), "the prophet" (#3), and possibly (the reading is damaged) "Jerusalem" (#5). The Arad ostraca also refer to "the king" (#24). These are all excavated inscriptions whose genuineness is not in doubt. The Arameans in what is now Syria spoke Aramaic (the CAL website seems to be jammed at the moment, but here's the Google cache version of their "Aramaic" article.) After the Babylonian Exile, the Persian Empire used Aramaic as its diplomatic language, which resulted in its being used all over the ancient Near East in the Persian period and widely for centuries thereafter. Again, anyone who knows anything about the history of the Semitic languages knows this. The article also makes the daft revisionist claim that "Judaism, Christianity and Islam are all part of Arab culture." If this is an example of "critical analysis" by the Axis of Logic, I'm not impressed. posted by Jim Davila | 11:48 AM ANNE RICE WATCH: There's lots more in the media about Anne Rice and her Jesus book and I don't have time to note all of it. But this paragraph struck me. It's in a New York Times article from 26 October: On the Internet she has challenged bloggers who dismiss her, on religious grounds and otherwise, as unqualified to take on the subject. "I tell them it's sincerely written and it's the Jesus of the Gospels," she said. Hmmm ... Anne Rice reads blogs. I'll let you know if I get any e-mail from her. posted by Jim Davila | 9:52 AM Wednesday, November 02, 2005 MORE ON ANNE RICE and her Jesus book from Beliefnet: Anne Rice: 'Stations on a Journey' That's a bummer, because it means we'll probably never see the resolution of that wild cliffhanger at the end of Taltos. But this seems to confirm my fear at the time I read it that she had written herself into a corner she couldn't get out of. Her books about witches and dark angels, she said, "were reflections of a world that didn't include redemption." Actually, I recall quite a bit of redemption in Memnoch the Devil, even if God didn't seem overly enthusiastic about the idea. Then, near the end of the piece: In the end, Rice seems to consider her new book a gift, both to Christians and to non-Christian fans of her previous work. "This is a book I offer to all Christians," she writes, "to the fundamentalists, to the Roman Catholics, to the most liberal Christians in the hope that my embrace of more conservative doctrines will have some coherence for them in the here and now of the book... The ellipsis is in the article. It will be very interesting to see how all of these readers react to this new book. The article also describes her faith journey from and back to the Catholic Church and looks a bit at her view of New Testament scholarship. posted by Jim Davila | 2:47 PM THAT BELONGS IN A MUSEUM, as Indiana Jones would say. I hope some philanthropist will see it that way, or at least will see to it that this lot of geniza fragments being sold by Christie's remains fully accessible to scholars for research. posted by Jim Davila | 10:15 AM DIGITALIZED SPECIAL COLLECTIONS are the subject of an interesting Library Journal article: Rarities Online Here's a (from my perspective) particularly interesting example: [Alice] Schreyer [special collections librarian at the University of Chicago] points to the Goodspeed Manuscript Collection Project at the University of Chicago. With a $250,000 award from the Institute of Museum and Library Services matched by $227,762 from the university, the project has created a remarkable digital collection of 65 Greek, Syriac, Ethiopian, Armenian, Arabic, and Latin manuscripts dating from the seventh to the 19th century, complete with software to scroll over and examine every part of the manuscripts in detail. The program, Schreyer says, began with a faculty member using the collection with a class but quickly evolved. “We really felt the research potential of the collection was of global interest to scholars, and we wanted to be able to share that worldwide,” Schreyer says. “It’s a collection that has not been heavily researched because it is all in Chicago.” It is now freely accessible, and such efforts epitomize the transformation of learning. In a curious old-media-mindset lapse, the article neglects to give URLs or links to the projects it cites, but you can access the Goodspeed New Testament Manuscript Collection by following this link. posted by Jim Davila | 10:01 AM SO YESTERDAY I spent the day driving to the Edinburgh airport, picking my family up from a holiday, bringing them home, and getting them settled in. Plus teaching a Hebrew class. So what happens while I'm away? The Israeli government arrests Hanan Eshel. Police arrest archaeologist suspected of ancient relic trade Apparently the charges are failing to inform the IAA of the purchase within 15 days and also "illegal excavation." A longer Hebrew version of the article is here, but be forewarned: the page gave my Firefox browser the Evil Rotating Beach Ball screen freeze. For more on the Leviticus scroll fragments in question, see here. There are further details in this Jerusalem Post article: Police probe leading archeologist Regarding the charges, it says: After purchasing the scroll, he [Eshel] said he had it photographed at a police lab, a claim police deny. There's been some discussion on the ANE List. Joseph I. Lauer has bee especially good at digging up references. It's really too soon to know what all this means or how it will play out. I have the highest regard for Hanan Eshel as a scholar and a friend and I can't imagine him deliberately breaking any antiquities laws. I believe there has been controversy on whether he should have dealt with the looters at all, though. That is a difficult question. Stay tuned. posted by Jim Davila | 9:51 AM Tuesday, November 01, 2005 AMEN ON ALL COUNTS. posted by Jim Davila | 9:47 AM KABBALAH CENTRE WOES in Tel Aviv: Kabbalah leader arrested over '£30,000 charge for fraudulent cancer cure'posted by Jim Davila | 9:05 AM ARAMAIC WATCH: Aramaic chat rooms as PSYOP? Make love, not jihad: PSYOP, OSINT efforts should tackle repression of romance My emphasis. posted by Jim Davila | 8:57 AM |
|
|||