| PaleoJudaica.com A weblog on ancient Judaism and its context E-mail: paleojudaica-at-talktalk-dot-net ("-at-" = "@", "-dot-" = ".") |
|
Tuesday, March 07, 2006 THIS SOUNDS LIKE A STRANGE "DOCUMENTARY." My comments are interspersed. It Began in JerusalemThe sixth century (BCE, I assume) was not 1000 years before the birth of Jesus. It was the 500s. I'm not sure what the "forced into slavery" bit is about. The Babylonian exile maybe? But they were exiled, not enslaved. From the mystery that surrounds the secretive burial and discovery in 1940 of the Dead Sea Scrolls to the formation of the Roman Empire, REVELATION examines the reign of terror that saw many Palestinian women commit suicide in mass protest.The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in 1947, not 1940. I don't know what the "reign of terror" and the suicidal "Palestinian" women are about and I don't feel inclined to speculate. The documentary attempts to prise apart the beginnings of Christianity from its Judaic past to its church of all nations present.Here, it seems, we come to the agenda of the film. However, the beginnings of Christianity are not prisable apart from it's Judaic past, so the attempt isn't likely to get very far. If this press release reflects the quality of the production and some producer actually paid good money to make it, they were ripped off. posted by Jim Davila | 10:39 AM A NEW JESUS MOVIE by an Egyptian producer is in the works: Egyptian producer plans first Arab film on Jesusposted by Jim Davila | 9:25 AM MORE ON THE WIESENTHAL CENTER/MUSLIM CEMETERY CONTROVERSY: Wiesenthal Center May Move Muslim GravesThis part doesn't seem to me to add up: Durgham Saif, a lawyer for the human rights group Karameh, which is involved in the court case, said he did not know about the plans to relocate graves but said moving them would not satisfy the group's demands.But according to media reports a parking lot had already been built over the proposed site of the Wiesenthal Center in the 1980s. Plus a hotel was built over another area of the cemetery in the 1920s, approved by the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem at the time. That doesn't decide this case either way, but I don't find Durgham Saif's argument here persuasive. posted by Jim Davila | 9:18 AM Monday, March 06, 2006 MORE PYRAMIDS TOO? I've already noted the discovery of an intact tomb in the Egyptian Valley of the Kings, which it now seems contained seven coffins and which is not far from King Tut's tomb. That's impressive, but just wait. In an article in Egypt Today (via Archaeologica News), Zahi Hawass drops this teaser about another discovery: “Some people put on perfume in the morning,” he says. “My perfume is the sand. If I don’t smell the sand every day, I will die. Egypt is still so rich. I made a discovery recently in Saqqara. I haven’t announced it yet, but it will show that you can still discover cachets and” He pauses, and it’s the long, dramatic pause for which he is famous on international television. “and even whole pyramids in Egypt.”Stay tuned! posted by Jim Davila | 4:27 PM MY PAPER "The Hekhalot Literature and the Early Jewish Apocalypses" has been accepted by the Early Jewish and Christian Mysticism Group for the Society of Biblical Literature meeting in Washington D.C. in November. Here's the abstract: This paper explores the relationship between the Hekhalot literature -- the pre-Kabbalistic corpus of mystical texts that give instructions on how to ascend (or "descend") to God's heavenly throne-chariot and to compel the angels to grant revelations -- and the verifiably Jewish apocalypses of the early centuries C.E. and earlier. The article views the Hekhalot literature from the heuristic social-scientific model of the practitioner (the "descender to the chariot") as "shaman/healer" and examines the apocalypses to determine which elements of this model already existed in the earlier period and whether these indicate a genetic relationship between the apocalyptic visionaries and the descenders to the chariot.The social-scientific model is the one presented in my book, Descenders to the Chariot: The People Behind the Hekhalot Literature. You can read an early version of the thesis of the book in my 1994 SBLSP article, "The Hekhalot Literature and Shamanism." posted by Jim Davila | 9:22 AM Sunday, March 05, 2006 RECENT CAVE EXCAVATIONS in the Dead Sea region have uncovered some important coins from the period of the Bar Kokhba revolt. I've probably covered this before, but I can't remember (and I'm unexpectedly in Edinburgh this weekend and kind of busy). This is a Netscape News report, found via last week's Explorator. Amazing Find Near the Dead Sea UPDATE (6 March): Yep, I had posts on it here and here almost three years ago. posted by Jim Davila | 9:57 AM Saturday, March 04, 2006 FIRECRACKERS IN NAZARETH CHURCH: Fireworks start melee at Nazareth shrineThis was really playing with fire and it's fortunate that it didn't turn out even worse. posted by Jim Davila | 9:36 AM "LUSTY AND SURE-FOOTED": The Charlotte Observer has a detailed report on the choral performance inspired by the Dead Sea Scrolls: Choral group pays homage to Scrollsposted by Jim Davila | 9:16 AM MADONNA is rumored to be looking to invest in some prime Israeli real estate: Old shack will give Madonna front-row seat for arrival of her MessiahThe story seems to have originated in the Hebrew publication Yedioth Ahronoth. Another article reports that: Yedioth Ahronoth said that the owner of a 100-year-old, ramshackle five-bedroom villa overlooking the Sea of the Galilee had been recently contacted several times by representatives of the superstar with a view to selling his property.If the rumor is true, I imagine this will be good for tourism. posted by Jim Davila | 9:10 AM THE SITE OF THE MUSEUM OF TOLERANCE is associated with a gruesome ancient episode according to the Jerusalem Post: Massacre at MamillaThe quotation is from historian James Parkes. posted by Jim Davila | 8:55 AM Friday, March 03, 2006 SNOW AT ST. MARY'S COLLEGE: ![]() I took this picture this morning. We don't get much snow in St. Andrews, but much of what we do get comes in the first half of March. According to tradition, the thorn tree on the left was planted by Mary Queen of Scots. posted by Jim Davila | 8:58 PM GILLES QUISPEL - 1916-2006 I am very sorry to relay the following news from Jack Sasson's Agade list: From a subscriber to the biblical-studies@yahoogroups.com:Requiescat in pace. Professor Quispel was almost 90 years old. And as I noted here recently, another renowned specialist in Gnosticism, R. McL. Wilson, just celebrated his 90th birthday. It seems that Gnosis is good not only for the soul, but also for the constitution. UPDATE: J. P. van de Giessen has a long post about Quispel in Dutch at the Aantekeningen bij de Bijbel blog. (Via a comment at Hypotyposeis.) posted by Jim Davila | 8:37 PM THOUGHTS ON ANTIQUITY, Chris Weimer's blog, has moved. You can find it now here. posted by Jim Davila | 2:36 PM THE LIVRES DE PAROLE EXHIBITION in Paris is reviewed by David Tresilian in Al Ahram: Canons of monotheismposted by Jim Davila | 9:34 AM COPTIC GOSPEL OF JUDAS WATCH: Expert doubts 'Gospel of Judas' revelationI'm glad the press is getting this message out a little more clearly. Robinson has not seen the text that National Geographic is working on, but assumes it is the same work assailed by Bishop Irenaeus of Lyons around A.D. 180. You can read the passage by Irenaeus at the Gospel of Judas page over at Peter Kirby's Early Christian Writings website. It remains to be seen whether Irenaeus' Gospel of Judas is the same as the Coptic one. And here's a preview of Robinson's new book: In The Secrets of Judas, a HarperSanFrancisco book on sale April 1, Robinson will describe secretive maneuvers in the United States, Switzerland, Greece and elsewhere over two decades to sell the "Judas" manuscript.posted by Jim Davila | 9:25 AM Thursday, March 02, 2006 PHOENICIAN TEMPLE DISCOVERED: Phoenician temple found in Sicilyposted by Jim Davila | 9:19 AM Wednesday, March 01, 2006 DA VINCI CODE REVIEW: I finally got around to reading The Da Vinci Code last fall. (I borrowed Grant Macaskill's copy, which he had bought from a charity shop, so both of us avoided the defilement of giving Dan Brown money.) The book has been in the news a good bit lately because of both the lawsuit and the upcoming movie. I've finally finished this brief review, which is so late that it's timely again. Warning: there are some spoilers below. The book is fun. The writing is lousy, but the plot is well constructed and Brown keeps you guessing and wanting to know what comes next. Robert Langdon and Sophie Neveu are sympathetic characters and I usually wanted things to come out well for them (but see below). Intellectually the book is a couple of notches above, say, The Mummy movie, but it gets too full of itself with its bogus scholarly pretensions. In The Mummy, when Evelyn (Rachel Weitz) starts to blither about "Bambridge scholars" one can't help but cringe, but at least Rachel Weitz is good to look at, and we know anyway that before she gets out more than a few sentences brigands will come crashing through the door waving their scimitars and shooting the place up. (Then Evelyn will take a scimitar off of one of them and kill him with it. The bad guys will have machine guns and the good guys only revolvers, but nevertheless the baddies will miss completely and Evelyn's husband, Rick [Brendan Fraser], and her brother, Jonathan [John Hannah], will pick off numerous baddies. Also, at least once during the battle one or more goodies will leap through a glass window without getting a scratch.) Unfortunately, Brown fails to follow this principle of administering his fake scholarship in small doses relieved by vigorous bouts of action. Rather, pages 304 to 367 or thereabouts consist of nonstop pseudo-intellectual drivel and well before I got to page 367 I was longing for Silas to burst in and shoot them all down so they would shut up. Now in one sense, I don't hold this idiocy against Brown any more than I hold it against The Mummy. They're both just stories and even though their both badly done, they're lots of fun. I do hold against him the pretty explicit claim that the historical evidence he presents in the book is real. Notably, the opening page lists as "Fact" that "All descriptions of artwork, architecture, documents and secret rituals in this novel are accurate." This just isn't so. He tries to get around this in the common questions page on his website, but not with great success: HOW MUCH OF THIS NOVEL IS TRUE? This isn't correct. For example, he has the Dead Sea Scrolls containing "Gnostic Gospels" and calls the Scrolls "Christian records" (p. 351). Kindly show me a Gnostic Gospel among the Dead Sea Scrolls. I don't want to belabor the historical inaccuracies in the book here, since they've been covered very thoroughly many times elsewhere. But for more information see here and here and here and here and here and here and here and here. The bad thing about the book is that many people will read it and think the ridiculous claims in it are true -- and Brown himself is partly to blame for this and he could have mitigated the problem instead of making it worse. The good thing is that it has gotten a lot of people interested in the Bible and in actual ancient Jewish and Christian history and that may lead some of them to learn more from reputable sources. Plus, it's an amusing read. posted by Jim Davila | 10:20 AM BIBLICAL STUDIES CARNIVAL III is out over at Rick Brannan's Ricoblog. posted by Jim Davila | 10:19 AM "THE DEVIL IS IN THE DETAIL." The details are nearly all wrong, but somehow that doesn't seem to matter in this case. The London Times has an informative article: Da Vinci judge turns back to page oneMy favorite bit was this: At this stage Mr Justice Peter Smith interjected from the bench. “It’s not surprising, given what happened in 1187.” The court was briefly silenced. “The loss of the kingdom of Jerusalem, thanks to their stupid master,” the judge explained. Knowing nods all round.Right. 1187. Of course. This judge seems to be the right man for the job. (Heads up, Grant Macaskill.) UPDATE: Also in the Times, Magnus Linklater sums up the situation nicely: This then must be the dilemma for those who seek to defend their own versions of made-up history: they can only sue and win if they can demonstrate that their ideas are fictional, invented and therefore entirely their own property. If, on the other hand, they succeed in proving that their research is genuine, and their investigations firmly based, then they have made a signal contribution to history — a history that belongs to us all. Their revelations become as public as the secrets of the Enigma Code, the Suez pact, or the British presidency of the European Union. Read it all. posted by Jim Davila | 10:06 AM THE LAST CATO -- Here we go again! Professor David Maltsberger of the Baptist University of the Américas e-mails a heads-up: Be watching for the big splash surrounding "The Last Cato" This is the first I've heard of it. posted by Jim Davila | 9:56 AM COPTIC GOSPEL OF JUDAS WATCH: But it's still cool. posted by Jim Davila | 9:40 AM SANLI URFA (known in antiquity as "Edessa"), the city that gave us the Syriac language, has its own newsletter, the Urfa Times. The current issue has a brief article on the city's history. posted by Jim Davila | 9:38 AM THE PIYYUT IS "IN" IN ISRAEL: The Piyyut is Jewish Soul Musicposted by Jim Davila | 9:27 AM |
|
|||