THE SECRETS OF JUDAS, by James M. Robinson is reviewed in "The redemption of Judas" (Waterloo Record) by William Klassen. He starts with an third-century ivory carving that he thinks may have been made by the same group that produced the Gospel of Judas. He also defends the National Geographic Society and their consultants on the project, of whom he is one. Excerpt:

For all its strengths, Robinson's book also has some serious flaws. He offers an extremely biased account of the events and negotiations which led to the publishing of the Judas manuscript and its public release by the National Geographic Society. He makes serious accusations against the museum in Geneva which owns the codex and National Geographic.

Some of the accusations are patently based on rumour and are, to my mind, totally false. For example, he indicates that the people whom National Geographic brought in as consultants and swore to six months of secrecy, were paid handsomely. As he puts it, they "have been bought off (no doubt with considerably more than 30 pieces of silver) and sworn to silence on a stack of Bibles -- or on a stack of papyrus leaves." As one of those consultants, I can assure Robinson that not a penny was paid to me, let alone any pieces of silver.

Robinson criticizes the National Geographic for resorting to sensationalism, but on several occasions offers his own bits of sensationalism. The discovery of the Gospel of Judas is a sensational event. Moreover, the way in which the 1,700-year-old manuscript survived a group of camel drivers drawing lots for it, to say nothing of the conniving of antiquity dealers and 15 years of disintegration in a safety deposit box, is nothing short of a miracle.