Wednesday, October 09, 2024

Review series on Fisch, Written for Us

ANCIENT JEW REVIEW: 2023 SBL Review Forum for Yael Fisch's Written for Us.

The book was published by Brill in 2023. There are four essays in this series. The first is now posted:

“The Art of Comparison: Yael Fisch’s Written for Us: Paul’s Interpretation of Scripture and the History of Midrash” (Christine Hayes)

[...]

After reading Fisch’s book I am convinced that Paul’s general hermeneutic should not be identified as a radicalization of Alexandrian allegory, or as allegory at all. And I can accept, based on Paul’s blend of the intertextual method featured in later rabbinic midrash with the terminology and content of allegory in Gal 4, that allegory and midrash are not always diametrically opposed, at least for Paul. Nevertheless, as Fisch herself recognizes and details, allegory and midrash differ in numerous ways. Moreover, they are not blended in the vast majority of works of ancient Jewish interpretation or in rabbinic literature, which suggests that their distinction as hermeneutical systems has heuristic value. ...

Visit PaleoJudaica daily for the latest news on ancient Judaism and the biblical world.